On Wed, Feb 6, 2013 at 9:33 PM, David Gerard dgerard@gmail.com wrote:
On 6 February 2013 18:46, Carcharoth carcharothwp@googlemail.com wrote:
On 2/6/13, Fred Bauder fredbaud@fairpoint.net wrote:
Nevertheless something that is never mentioned in a nonfiction book or journal article over 250 years could be said to have dropped from the canon of knowledge and could then be archived.
Maybe, but I don't think you can generalise. You have to inspect each individual case. It *is* important that contemporary coverage exists as a check and balance to past coverage, but past coverage can provide historical context in other articles, even if it ultimately is insufficient to support a stand-alone article.
The real problem is that Wikipedia's sourcing rules *mostly* work *most* of the time - they are not philosophically watertight, and trying to treat them as if they were leads to silliness and frustration. So I'm just expressing my frustration. And probably being silly.
- d.
It is actually worse than that. Wikipedias rules taken as a whole used to be about enabling editors to work, even in areas of dispute. I seriously doubt that is a tenable defense of the rules as enforced these days.