Thanks! : )
In that case, I'd like to suggest the following:
1. Blocking/banning notices (the templates and the Blockedtext and
Autoblockedtext messages) should be sensitively worded and contain
clear instructions on a) the proper course of appeals, if there are
any viable options, or else an apologetic explanation that there are
no viable options, b) asking for courtesy blankings, deletions and
the occasional oversight (it is far too difficult to figure out how to
contact the OTRS), and c) how to get advice (Editor assistance, I
guess, since the Association of Members Advocates and Mentorship
Committee are both rather dead).
2. Said notices should use relaxing colours - light blue, lavender,
green - and avoid stressful red Xs.
3. Blocking templates should be placed in the 'Blocking reason' slot,
not on the editor's talk page, where they would show up on Google.
4. The OTRS ought to be given more room to work in terms of courtesy
blankings, deletions and the occasional oversight.
5. Please, pretty please, do not discuss the courtesy blankings etc.
publicly, on-wiki. This defeats the point. Use email.
6. Please do not continue to discuss, in a hurtful way, the banned
users when they are not even appealing. Also see
[[Wikipedia:Banning_policy#Dealings_with_banned_users]] where it
states 'Wikipedia's hope for banned users is that they will leave
Wikipedia with their pride and dignity intact, whether permanently or
for the duration of their ban. As such, it is inappropriate to bait
banned users or take advantage of their ban to mock them.'
Thanks,
Armed Blowfish
On 11/08/07, Marc Riddell <michaeldavid86(a)comcast.net> wrote:
on 8/11/07 8:50 AM, Armed Blowfish at
diodontida.armata(a)googlemail.com
wrote:
On 11/08/07, Thomas Dalton
<thomas.dalton(a)gmail.com> wrote:
However,
talk pages are shown on Google, and block logs aren't... and
it is entirely conceivable that a banned user might not want the fact
that he or she is banned to show up on Google.
They should have thought about that before doing something
blockworthy, then, shouldn't they?
Wikipaedia has a right to block people, blocking people being part of
Wikipaedia's self-determination, but there are still things Wikipaedia
can and should do to make the process as painless as possible. The
goal should only be to prevent the person from editing, not hurt the
person.
Also, as a banned user, I must ask you to not imply that
banned/blocked users 'deserve' to be banned/blocked.
Armed Blowfish
Excellent points, AB. This has to do with how the culture regards its
people.
Marc Riddell
_______________________________________________
WikiEN-l mailing list
WikiEN-l(a)lists.wikimedia.org
To unsubscribe from this mailing list, visit:
http://lists.wikimedia.org/mailman/listinfo/wikien-l