On 10/10/06, Guy Chapman aka JzG <guy.chapman(a)spamcop.net> wrote:
On Mon, 9 Oct 2006 19:49:39 -0500, "Parker Peters"
<onmywayoutster(a)gmail.com> wrote:
> Yes, I read it. I also reviewed the
contribution history, which is
> after all the main thing.
As did I. And I came to the opposite conclusion.
It's my opinion that the
edits might have been poorly phrased but they met the standard of RS, V,
and
were consistent with writings in other articles we
have regarding the
same
subject matter.
And if you read Naconkantari's recent post you'll see that the IP
address was the same each time.
And, even if a sockpuppet of a "name.." editor, the important thing is to
assume good faith and at least try to get a new editor to respect others and
policy on wikipedia.
As the edits didn't rise to the level of vandalism (and still don't,
regardless of what you or Naconkantari who was edit warring will try to
claim), the blocking is still out of line.
The diffs were forwarded to Jimbo directly in a private
email, before his
public request for diffs. I'm waiting for his
private response on the
matter.
So we have one example which is a righteous block and one about which
you are prepared to make vague arm-waving assertions but not present
the evidence here.
No, I'm respectfully waiting Jimbo's wishes, though that's since gone by a
bit now that Naconkantari has posted, and it ought to be easy enough for you
to look at the contributions lists and page history yourself instead of
violating [[WP:DENSE]].
I think I'm through with this.
You appear to have been for a while and just trying to make some sad game of
a real issue.
Parker