This section of the BLP is kind of rot:
Editors should remove any contentious material about living persons
that is unsourced, relies upon sources that do not meet standards
specified in Wikipedia:Verifiability, or is a conjectural
interpretation of a source (see Wikipedia:No original research). Where
the material is derogatory and unsourced or poorly sourced, the
three-revert rule does not apply. These principles apply to
biographical material about living persons found anywhere in
Wikipedia, including user and talk pages.
What if the material is accurate and can be checked with a quick
google search? Wouldn't a better formulation be:
Editors should add proper sources to contentious material about living
persons. If such a source cannot be found, the material should be
removed. Where the material is derogatory and unsourceable, relies on
improper sources (see Wikipedia:Verifiability), or is a conjectural
interpretation of a source (see Wikipedia:No original research), the
three revert rule does not apply.
Derogatory opinions about living persons on user and talk pages must
follow the above rules. Contentious or negative biographical material
on user and talk pages must be verifiable. If properly contextualized,
contentious material from questionable sources may be discussed, but
the problems with the material and the sources must be clearly
identified, and such material may be removed if the discussion has
ended or is not contributing to the development of the article. When
in doubt, derogatory material that is not properly sourceable should
WikiEN-l mailing list
To unsubscribe from this mailing list, visit:
Your idea may be fine in theory but isn't the burden on the author to adequatly source
his articles to begin with? One would think he would be in the best position to do so.
Further, such a change would allow material to remain in the article far too long because
we all know that most folks won't go the the trouble of finding the sources. Of
course, not all sources are available via a "quick google search."
Just my thoughts,