On Fri, Apr 30, 2010 at 1:38 PM, Charles Matthews
<charles.r.matthews(a)ntlworld.com> wrote:
Marc Riddell wrote:
I still do
not understand fully much of the decision-making process that goes into
matters such as deciding on a specific format policy. But what I do see
throughout the encyclopedia is an arbitrariness in form and structure that
greatly detracts from the professionalism of the Project. A reader is coming
to the encyclopedia looking for information on a particular subject. That
information should be presented in a consistent, reliable, familiar form.
This form becomes the "signature" of the encyclopedia. As the Wikipedia
Project matures, it is important that the decision-making processes
regarding such basic issues as its very form and structure mature as well.
So you need to be talking to someone like [[User:Tony1]], an advocate of
said type of "professionalism". But of course there is more to be said
here.
Naturally since most editors are "amateurs", in all the senses (unpaid,
doing it for the love of it, and people with an appreciation of the
site), anything that happens to the Manual of Style ought to be
compatible with retaining such amateurism (in a good sense). Note that
very complex sets of rules for formatting do add a barrier to entry; as
your example shows, it may not be so easy to appreciate the current
state of the MoS as compatible with "you may edit right now".
In other words, and this has played out on the site, it is not true that
the advocates of a "professional approach" have all the answers. It is
rather easier to effect changes to the Manual, than to ensure that the
consensus about what a Manual page should contain translates into a
shared understanding across the whole community. In fact the assumption
that it does would rest on either of two assumptions: people are paid
and so have a direct stake in following an imposed "house style", or the
community is small enough so that everyone can track the debates that
will affect them.
Is this an old thread or a new one that I missed? I'd like to read the
rest of the thread if it is still available.
Carcharoth