Ray Saintonge wrote:
Your statement that "the other ideas are
normally all wrong" is a
POV. If your criticism depends on a POV then it too is a POV. A
scientific experiment that shows something to be wrong is not the
same as one that fails to show it right. To say that something which
is not science is necessarily pseudoscience is a textbook application
of the fallacy of [[False dilemma]].
I never made such an assertion (that all non-science is
pseudoscience). I said that pseudoscience is often wrong. So could you
give me an example of a pseudoscience which is actually 'right'?
Your request is illogical. It asks for something right when it is
wrong by definition. If I see something as "right" I would not call it
pseudoscience.
Ec