Not at all. We're just engaging in a fun debate over an issue which doesn't make any difference about anything at all, and hopefully learning a little bit about copyright law in the process.
Hear, hear! The example in question isn't really relevant, it's the basic principles behind it we are debating. I certainly enjoy these debates, and I'm glad you do too. I very much doubt this debate will actually result in any action or change in policy, but hopefully it will get people thinking and learning while having a bit of fun.