On 2/28/06, Matt Brown <morven(a)gmail.com> wrote:
On 2/27/06, Tony Sidaway <f.crdfa(a)gmail.com>
wrote:
The nominator in this case is a suspiciously new
editor who has
precisely one edit in article space (inserting a "POV" template).
Nevertheless with his *ninth* edit he nominated for deletion an
article about a reasonably well established webcomic, and to date he
has made some 30 edits to the AfD.
Something stinks.
I don't see any obvious connection with another user, though, and
don't think sockpuppet witch-hunts are generally productive.
Nor I. But is this the caliber of editor we're attracting these days?
This is a perfectly good, encyclopedic article about verifiable,
referenced webcomic. What on earth is it doing on AfD in the first
place? When did Wikimedia start putting up signs saying "we've run
out of paper, please delete some articles to make more room?"
As the number of registered users approaches infinity, the probability
of running across an ignorant editor or troll approaches 1. (Hm, I just
came up with that off the bat. Something to add to Raul's laws if it
isn't there already.)
John