On May 29, 2006, at 9:37 AM, Raphael Wegmann wrote:
Yes, Wikipedia publishes anti-Semitic cartoons as
well, but they
are published on the article about "anti-Semitism" resp.
"new anti-Semitism". I wouldn't complain about publishing the
J-P cartoons on the Islamophobia article.
Wait a sec. We are talking about putting
the cartoons in an article
*on the J-P cartoons*, right? AFAIK, no-one is suggesting the cartoons
be included in the [[Islam]] article, or even [[2005 Islamic events]]
(if we have such an article). So, you think it's utterly wrong to
include the cartoons in an article * devoted solely to them *, but it
would be fine to include them in an article on a general subject of
which they are an (arguable) example? Does this make any sense to