2015-09-27 23:03 GMT+02:00 Thad Guidry <thadguidry@gmail.com>:

I have added my viewpoint to the P190 Discussion page.

Great, thanks!

 

Are you seriously saying that a Talk Page (where many are 2 - 10 pages scrollable) is the culmination of a definition of a property in Wikidata ?

In theory, only the top box should be needed. In practice, since everything in the Wikimedia movement is a work in progress, the talk page are almost always worth reading, especially if you have doubts on how to use it.

 

You expect folks to read 10 pages of Talk to fully understand the intent and how to use a Property in Wikidata ?

No, _I_ do not expect "folks" to read it. But I do expect people who want to improve the use of a property to read it before they setup their own definitions of that property.