2012/11/30 Avenue <email@example.com>
On Fri, Nov 30, 2012 at 2:57 PM, Denny Vrandečić <firstname.lastname@example.org> wrote:
Unfortunately, CC-BY-SA and ODBL are not compatible. You can not take content licensed under one license and republish it under the other license. Thus follows that using ODBL for Wikidata does not relieve us from *any* of the possible legal issues that are mentioned here due to Wikidata using CC0 as a license.
I think we are talking about different legal issues. My main concern is about external databases, with rights held by other organisations, that we wish to host on Wikidata (in whole or in substantial part).
See my earlier post (http://lists.wikimedia.org/pipermail/wikidata-l/2012-November/001239.html) for an example, based on the data in http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_ceremonial_counties_of_England and the infoboxes for various county articles listed within. This data is licensed by the UK government under the Open Government License (OGL, http://www.nationalarchives.gov.uk/doc/open-government-licence/)I believe UK editors would be breaking their country's law if they uploaded a significant portion of this database to Wikidata without following the terms of the OGL. These include giving credit and linking to the license where possible. They could probably do this in an adhoc fashion through the reference field, but it would be much better to have proper support for license tracking built in.
Having different licenses for different data items in Wikidata, as was suggested here, is not possible, as single data items are not licensable.My suggestion was that we keep track of licenses for different databases held in Wikidata, not for each individual item.
If Wikidata was a collection of databases, like e.g. OKFN's DataHub, then it would make sense to provide for different licenses for each of these databases. But Wikidata does not have any notion of different databases. You cannot take a database and simply upload it to Wikidata.Wikidata can certainly be thought of as a collection of databases (or parts of databases), regardless of whether Wikidata itself distinguishes between them.
I've only played around a little with Wikidata, and I'll take your word for it that simple uploads of databases are impossible. But based on what Wikidata promises to do, it must still be possible to upload them somehow.