In the light of all these discussions about what Wikibooks' scope is, I have drafted
proposed rewrite of What is Wikibooks here:
The idea behind this is:
to define inclusion criteria (ie getting away from the idea that anything not specifically
disallowed is allowed)
to be positive about what we are here for by having a positive definition
to cut out a lot of advice on WB:WIW which elongates the guidance without saying anything
people would dispute
a number of other existing proposals are effectively merged into it
I have also taken an idea given to be by RobinH - that policies should say in them
what happens if they are infringed, and added an enforcement section.
I don't intend my draft to be perfect - please go ahead and improve it.
All constructive comments would be welcome!