Re: [Publicpolicy] Voting list recommendation for the copyright vote, June 20th

Dear All, since we got hold of the voting list for the copyright vote, we prepared recommendations that I sent to over 20 MEPs in JURI that we hope will vote against the most damaging proposals (including article 13) and in favour of the good ideas on exceptions. We only give recommendations on articles: 3, 4, 5, 11, and 13 as well as the exceptions: Freedom of Panorama (CAs 56 and 57) as well as User extracts from pre-existing works and other subject matter in content uploaded or made available by users (Cas 58 and 59) - so called User Generated Content exception. For the remaining articles and corresponding amendments we provide no specific recommendation as to the vote. In summary, we present the following recommendations: On *article 3* we recommend voting against CA 4 (and corresponding CAs in recitals), instead we indicate specific amendments filed by members of JURI that in our opinion define text and data mining exception better. On *article 4* we recommend voting in favor of CA 6 (and corresponding CAs 23 to CA 26) On *article 5* we recommend voting in favor of CA 7 (and corresponding CAs 27 to CA 30) On *new exceptions (FoP, UGC)* we recommend voting in favor of CA 56 (and CA 57) as well as CA 58 (and CA 59) On *article 11* we recommend voting *against CA 12* (and corresponding CAs) and *in favor of** CA 12bis* (and corresponding CA 20bis and CA 41bis) that are the alternative Compromise Amendments On *article 13* we recommend voting *against CA 14* (and corresponding CAs) and *in favor of** CA 14bis* (and corresponding CA 47bis to CA 50bis) that are the alternative Compromise Amendments. In case CA 14 is adopted, we believe the negative consequence can be somehow mitigated by voting in favor of CA 2. Both IMCO 56 and AM 672 provide that the access gotten under one exception may not be used to exercise rights gotten under another exception - we find this approach harmful to the rights of users and legitimate uses of lawfully accessed content. We recommended voting *against **IMCO 56 and AM 672* as indicated in the document. Let’s hope that the vote will be at least partially along our line on the topic. Best wishes, Anna Anna Mazgal EU Policy Advisor Wikimedia anna(a)wikimedia.be @a2na mobile: +32 487 222 945 51 Rue du Trône BE-1050 Brussels _______________________________________________ Publicpolicy mailing list Publicpolicy(a)lists.wikimedia.org https://lists.wikimedia.org/mailman/listinfo/publicpolicy