Good stuff, overall. :-)

Re: slide 30 - "Do analysis on all the uses of the star icon (watch list) and bookmark icon in a systematic way, considering all the uses of each"
There was a brief mention of this in May Galloway's Wikimania2014 presentation. See this slide:
https://docs.google.com/presentation/d/1VYGOLDKQ4Sntv9UgkH34KUk_FyjAaUvc1eiocF_x8dc/edit#slide=id.g370b74046_0112
I think there was also a related page on mw.o but I can't find it.
I would strongly caution against using the 5 pointed star icon for yet another meaning (especially as it is so prominently used in both Chrome/Firefox interfaces as a plain browser-bookmark, and prominently within wikis as the add-to-watchlist link.)
The "downward arrow (towards a horizontal line, or from a cloud)" seem to be somewhat common alternative: https://www.google.ca/search?q=offline+save+icon&tbm=isch - I'd recommend the former.

Re: slide 42 - "Currently the Android"  [the sentence cuts off there].

Thanks for sharing!


On Thu, Feb 2, 2017 at 12:57 PM, Abbey Ripstra <aripstra@wikimedia.org> wrote:
Hi Everybody! 

Here is the report for this study, where we tested three (online to offline) ideas with a set of users we could reach from here in SF. 

Please check it out, and respond here with any questions, thoughts, interesting info that could inform our thinking further, etc. A few things to note: 

  • The feedback in this report has already been incorporated into the prototypes, where needed for our next round of research. (Thanks reading web team!)
  • We will continue the testing in India because it is MUCH easier to reach our target users there.
  • We will build on the set of learnings in this report with the outcomes of the research in India.
  • The recruit for research in India is starting now, and testing will begin within a week or so. 
  • We will upload this to commons and can post it in the next update
More to follow! 

--

_______________________________________________
reading-wmf mailing list
reading-wmf@lists.wikimedia.org
https://lists.wikimedia.org/mailman/listinfo/reading-wmf




--
Nick Wilson (Quiddity)
Community Liaison, WMF