On Wed, Jun 3, 2015 at 10:04 AM, Brian Gerstle <bgerstle(a)wikimedia.org>
wrote:
> My question is: why does the default behavior need to change? Wouldn't
> continuing with the default behavior allow people to continue using the
> "rawcontinue" behavior for as long as we want to support it—without making
> any changes?
>
The decision to change the default came out of the same concerns that led
to the improved action=help output and some of the other work I've been
doing lately: We want to lower the barriers for using our API, which means
that the default shouldn't be something user-hostile.
The raw continuation is deceptively simple: it looks straightforward, but
if you're using it with a generator, multiple prop modules, and meta or
list modules, your client code has to know when to ignore the returned
continuation for the generator, when to remove a module from prop and then
when to re-add it, and when to remove the meta or list modules. I wouldn't
be that surprised to learn that more people have it wrong than correct if
their code supports using prop modules with generators.
The new continuation actually is simple: you send the equivalent of
array_merge( $originalParams, $continueParams ) and it just works.
Yes, some of the same could be said for making format=json&formatversion=2
the default. In this case the formatversion=1 output is just annoying
rather than actually hostile (although representing boolean true as a
falsey string comes close), so at this time there's no plan to make that
breaking change.
--
Brad Jorsch (Anomie)
Software Engineer
Wikimedia Foundation
