Thanks for your message,

I have seen the mail from August and I think we have already given the rationale within this update.

As a language oriented project (all the wikisources are), we want to give full support to our language. That's why we were:

I don't think this can be achieved in any other foo.source projects alone, so the need is there.

If we add the reason given by Gerard: neapolitan-language speakers are not second class citizens, and so: We have preferred to work under the mul.wikisource umbrella until we are ready for the jump, just to make the things right.

Best regards,
and thanks for including me,
C.R.


2015-09-11 4:10 GMT+02:00 MF-Warburg <mfwarburg@googlemail.com>:
The last time this was brought up (in August), Antony said the following about it. As I see, C. Russo was not included in the mail, so I guess he did not see it. Therefore I'm copying it below.

>>
The request for Neapolitan Wikisource says it can't be hosted at Italian Wikisource because it's a different language. However, Neapolitan is already hosted at Italian Wikisource (it.wikisource.org/wiki/Categoria:Testi_in_napoletano), and there is a longstanding practice of hosting texts in "dialects" (including separate languages that are perceived as dialects) at the Wikisource of the local prestige language. Indeed, Italian Wikisource hosts texts in many languages of Italy (it.wikisource.org/wiki/Categoria:Testi_in_altre_lingue), including Griko, which isn't even Romance.

I'd like to see a stronger reason why Neapolitan texts can't be hosted at it-ws before approving the application.
<<



2015-09-10 8:51 GMT+02:00 C. Russo <stolatstolatstolatstolat@gmail.com>:
Dear all,

I want to bring to the attention of the Langcom that there is an update on the application for a neapolitan wikisource, which is pending evaluation since 2011.

The updated status of the neapolitan wikisource project is as follows:
- More than 3000 proofread pages
- Three or more contributors during the last 9 months
- Two or more contributors working intensively during more than 1 year
Localisation complete
- Biggest language in mul.wikisource by number of proofread pages and growing
- Iso code and long-term running wikipedia

We need the project to be activated:
- We'll provide better tools within our own language domain
- We'll provide better access to our native speakers and literates
- It is a minority language and time passes while the speaking population gets older (and the contributors too)
- We'll provide easy access to the humanity to the public domain in our language. This is now simply getting diluted into mul.wikisource, it.wikisource or en.wikisource, just as our books and songs are diluted and lost into the libraries of all over the world. We believe that a dedicated project is the best solution in order to support a language that cannot be fully deployed as a project by means of perpetual incubation into another project , specially when the other projects have no explicit scope or interest for neapolitan language (just as all the wikisources were opened in 2006)


_______________________________________________
Langcom mailing list
Langcom@lists.wikimedia.org
https://lists.wikimedia.org/mailman/listinfo/langcom