I want to start a conversation. [...Larry says, in his
blog]
I. Problem? What problem?
So, you didn’t know that Wikipedia has a porn problem?
Let me say what I do not mean by “Wikipedia’s porn
problem.” I do not mean simply that Wikipedia has a lot of
porn. That’s part of the problem, but it’s not even the main
problem. I’m 100% OK with porn sites. I defend the right of
people to host and view porn online. I don’t even especially
mind that Wikipedia has porn. There could be legitimate
reasons why an encyclopedia might want to have some “adult
content.”
No, the real problem begins when Wikipedia features some of
the most disgusting sorts of porn you can imagine, while being
heavily used by children. But it’s even more complicated than
that, as I’ll explain.
(Note, the following was co-written by me and several other
people. I particularly needed their help finding the links.)
Here is the short version:
Wikipedia and other websites of the Wikimedia Foundation
(WMF) host a great deal of pornographic content, as well as
other content not appropriate for children. Yet, the Wikimedia
Foundation encourages children to use these resources. Google,
Facebook, YouTube, Flickr, and many other high-profile sites
have installed optional filters to block adult content from
view. I believe the WMF sites should at a minimum install an
optional, opt-in filter, as the WMF Board agreed to do in
2011. I understand that the WMF has recently stopped work on
the filter and, after a period of community reaction, some
Board members have made it clear that they do not expect this
filter to be finished and installed. Wikipedians, both
managers and rank-and-file, apparently do not have enough
internal motivation to do the responsible thing for their
broad readership.
But even that is too brief. If you really want to
appreciate Wikipedia’s porn problem, I’m afraid you’re going
to have to read the following.
Feel free to repost!
There is further discussion of this, with Larry in
attendance, on Wikipediocracy.com:
Note that the related thread is in the "Sexualisation"
subforum, which is only accessible to registered Wikipediocracy
members. Registration is free though, and anyone wishing to have
a look is welcome to join up and participate!