Carol's productive contributions outweigh the trolling she's been put through and occasional policy issue she has run in to, at least not to the point of warranting a site ban. Neotarf is being topic-banned from a project they were a productive contributor to on a handful of flimsy diffs. I'd bet $20 that either no civility block sticks to Eric or it ends in another arb case within four months. Eric's a prolific content contributor who has for at least two years regularly used the same gendered slur and refused to acknowledge a problem with it or with his behavior in general. Like Betacommand, the content contributions driven off by his behavior greatly outnumber his own. The decision as it stands is ENWP's arbcom explicitly saying they don't care about one of five aimed metrics WMF to back strategic priorities.
----
Kevin Gorman