This is messier than I expected it to be. I'm surprised by how much everyone differs in their confidence of exactly what The Problem is.

I would prefer moderation, but I'd settle for some rules if they're actually enforced. This free-for-all sort of atmosphere where people are shooting each other's posts and opinions down is reminding me a little too strongly of some article talk pages that I've chosen not to participate in. Dismissing someone's concerns because you haven't experienced them, for example, ought not to be considered cool.