Re: [discovery] [MediaWiki-l] Search feature / Change in behaviour

Thanks Karsten, I created : - https://phabricator.wikimedia.org/T167798 - https://phabricator.wikimedia.org/T167800 Please feel free to add more context: - screenshots would greatly help I think - step by step example to reproduce T167800 would be great I did not created the issue related to ranking since it's nearly impossible to debug them without precise examples and a full dataset, but feel free to add some comments about it to T167798 if you think it's important. Thanks! On Mon, Jun 12, 2017 at 5:39 PM, [[kgh]] &lt;mediawiki(a)kghoffmeyer.de <mailto:mediawiki@kghoffmeyer.de>> wrote: Heiya and ouch, thanks a lot Chris for making me aware of the post. You mail went directly to the spam folder and David's did not even get that far (lost in the void :( ). In future I will just monitor the archive for new posts to be sure. :| ad 1 - highlighting) Affirmative, so one hast to access the page to see where exactly the phrase shows up. ad 2 - ranking) I cannot tell for sure but I my impression is yes. ad 3 - missing content) This was part of Tom's oberservation, but yes I experience that too. Even after running "rebuildtextindex.php" pages did not show up in the search - not even title matches. I have still one wiki on MW 1.23 so I could do before and after testing to be able to provide a better picture. So I guess it is time to move to phabricator. Cheers and thanks a lot for your feedback. Karsten quote lost e-mail: Hi, to clarify: 1) highlighting: When searching with double quotes (phrase search) only the title is displayed in the search results, the text snippet with the page content snippet is not displayed. But here the same number results is found between 1.23 and 1.27 it just lacks some snippet for the page content? 2) ranking: When searching without quotes, the snippet for the page content is shown but the results are worse (compared to the phrase search or compared to MW1.23?) 3) missing content: When searching wikitext tags: a lot of pages are missing: this is not a highlighting problem here: when I searched for *<tag> *with MW 1.23: 50 pages were found, now with MW 1.27 only 3 are found. Does this problem apply only to tags, are there missing pages when searching normal text? It looks like 3 different bugs to me, could you please confirm. We'll then be able to create some phabricator tickets to continue the discussion there. Thanks! Am 02.06.2017 um 00:14 schrieb Chris Koerner: _______________________________________________ discovery mailing list discovery(a)lists.wikimedia.org <mailto:discovery@lists.wikimedia.org> https://lists.wikimedia.org/mailman/listinfo/discovery <https://lists.wikimedia.org/mailman/listinfo/discovery>