On 30/05/07, Matthew Brown <morven(a)gmail.com> wrote:
On 5/28/07, Brianna Laugher
<brianna.laugher(a)gmail.com> wrote:
There are around 10 people who qualify. I've
emailed most of them. So
far no one has written about themselves to put up an entry. As soon as
they do, they're welcome to be listed there.
It looks to me like the requirement is much too high to be listed.
The page doesn't title itself as 'Our very very very very best
photographers', after all.
Furthermore, the page itself doesn't mention inclusion criteria AT
ALL; only the talk page does. That makes it rather misleading.
It's unusual, for a wiki page, but this page doesn't really have a
wiki audience. Not sure how it's misleading.
What do you think is a reasonable critierion? How many people could be
comfortably listed on such a page? A dozen or so strikes me as about
right. After that, who's going to pay attention?
cheers,
Brianna