Nobody is questioning the need to be transparent to our users about what data we’re collecting, how long this data is retained and what it’s being used for. But I see a thread full of handwaving statements about “what users really want”, in contrast to a pretty straightforward truth that nobody who participated in this thread would challenge:
which departs from the standard in a significant way.
I don’t see myself blessing a proposal that represents “a significant departure from the standard” and I’d love to see more substantial evidence on user expectations to justify this.