[Wiktionary-l] Klingon Wiktionary closed

Yann Forget yann at forget-me.net
Wed Apr 4 08:31:47 UTC 2007


Hello,

Dmcdevit wrote:
(...)
> Your notion that Klingon, the language of a fictional alien race on a 
> popular American television show, has some kind of existence separate 
> from its origins is absurd. It only needs to be rejected for its 
> present: which is as a linguistically unimportant, functionally 
> nonexistent, and educationally useless language to write a dictionary in.

I agree with the closing of this Wiktionary, and this argument says it all.

> Dominic

Best regards,

Yann



More information about the Wiktionary-l mailing list