[Wikipedia-l] Wikipedia English English

Ray Saintonge saintonge at telus.net
Mon Sep 19 14:30:46 UTC 2005


Jack & Naree wrote:

>On 19/09/05, Mike Kuklinski <admin at kuattech.com> wrote: 
>  
>
>>On 18/09/05, Jack & Naree <jack.macdaddy at gmail.com> wrote:
>>    
>>
>Americans seem to want to believe that they speak English, and we speak 
>British English in England (meaning Britain!). They are wrong. They speak a 
>dialect of our language, called American-English, an offshoot from the main 
>trunk if you will, which has evolved somewhat independently of English.
> American-English is an out and out dialect of English. How can English 
>English be a dialect of English?
>
I presume you are referring to the dialect of the ruling classes.

>(NB, I'm basing my definition on the written word not the regional spoken 
>dialects of England).
>
That does narrow your outlook.

> if you want
>  
>
>>proper English, look to Shakespearean early Modern English.
>>    
>>
>Incorrect, if you want proper English, go to England; that is where the 
>English language is spoken by the English people, of England.
>  
>
Which part of England?




More information about the Wikipedia-l mailing list