[Wikipedia-l] Re: Wikipedia spanks Encarta, Brockhaus
Lothar Kimmeringer
wikipedia at kimmeringer.de
Sat Oct 2 19:55:29 UTC 2004
On Sat, 02 Oct 2004 20:41:12 +0200, Andre Engels wrote:
> I'd be interested to see this list of 66 topics and what scores the three
> candidates got. Also - did they use the German or the English Wikipedia?
German Wikipedia as already said.
Here's the list (replicated by hand). The words are kept
in German. You should switch to a non-proportional font.
The first number in the table is the number of characters,
the second number the qualitiy (1 is not good, 5 is best,
0 means not existant).
EP: Encarta Pro
BH: Brockhaus
WP: Wikipedia
==========================================================
Scientific area
==========================================================
Philosophy
Sprachspiele (easy)
EP 4004/3
BH 10831/4
WP 1198/3
kathegorischer Imperativ (medium)
EP 3929/4
BH 564/3
WP 7415/5
transzendentale Apperzeption (hard)
EP 430/2
BH 311/3
WP 5178/3
Mathematics
Asymtote (easy)
EP 2093/3
BH 796/3
WP 2365/5
Fibonacci-Zahlen (medium)
EP 2446/3
BH 2678/4
WP 3510/4
Banachraum (hard)
EP 0/3 * here I'm not sure how a non-existant
article can be "average"
BH 1348/2
WP 6911/5
Physics
Trägheitsmoment (easy)
EP 127/1
BH 939/4
WP 4996/5
Mößbauer-Effekt (medium)
EP 2123/2
BH 2970/4
WP 632/3
Bose-Einstein-Kondensation (hard)
EP 2567/3
BH 8072/5
WP 2997/4
Chemistry
Massenwirkungsgesetz (easy)
EP 2390/4
BH 870/2
WP 1335/5
polyaromatische Kohlenwasserstoffe (medium)
EP 3400/5
BH 632/1
WP 457/2
FTIR-Spektroskopie (hard)
EP 1131/1
BH 909/3
WP 715/5
Psychology
Rorschachtest (easy)
EP 847/5
BH 662/5
WP 811/2
Elektrakomplex (medium)
EP 2358/4
BH 320/4
WP 790/2
Hawthorne-Effekt (hard)
EP 951/4
BH 791/4
WP 1347/4
Biology
Gnu (easy)
EP 1826/5
BH 661/2
WP 3903/3
genetischer Fingerabdruck (medium)
EP 4493/3
BH 13630/5
WP 4837/2
t-RNS (hard)
EP 1073/1
BH 886/2
WP 762/4
Computer Science
Algorithmus (easy)
EP 7476/3
BH 15441/5
WP 15417/5
Kryptographie (medium)
EP 20636/4
BH 16072/5
WP 7494/5
Backus-Naur-Form (hard)
EP 0/0
BH 4666/5
WP 9350/5
Medicine
Hyperventilation (easy)
EP 482/4
BH 587/4
WP 2073/5
Fontanelle (medium)
EP 348/3
BH 519/2
WP 0/0 * exist now
Amygdala (hard)
EP 230/3
BH 0/0
WP 376/2
Geography/geology
Grundmoräne (easy)
EP 618/5
BH 172/3
WP 949/2
Black Somker (medium)
EP 3005/5
BH 342/4
WP 2600/5
Epeirophorese (Kontinentalverschiebung) (hard)
EP 0/0 * only exists with the german word
BH 2325/5
WP 0/5 * number of characters missing, the
* article exist
Electronics
Dolby Digital (easy)
EP 0/0
BH 2025/5
WP 865/4
DVB-T (medium)
EP 2130/2
BH 807/3
WP 10824/5
photonische Netze (hard)
EP 0/0
BH 3997/4
WP 0/0
==========================================================
Social area
==========================================================
Current events
Hartz-Reform (easy) * strange definition of easy - even
* the bureaucrats don't understand it
* completely ;-)
EP 3499/1
BH 1837/3
WP 17765/5
Yukos/Jukos (medium)
EP 0/0
BH 829/3
WP 5720/5
3. Golfkrieg (insbesondere sunnitisches Dreieck) (hard)
EP 70338/5 * wow
BH 7766/2
WP 30838/4
World history
Boxeraufstand (easy)
EP 9134/4
BH 7572/4
WP 9479/2
McCarthy (medium)
EP 3192/4
BH 448/2
WP 3124/3
Philipp Scheidemann (Weimarer Republik) (hard)
EP 2334/4
BH 2388/5
WP 3390/3
Politics
Horst Köhler (easy)
EP 3887/4
BH 592/2
WP 9086/5
Vietcong (medium)
EP 17103/4
BH 36219/5
WP 24768/2
Plebiszit (hard)
EP 7179/5
BH 856/3
WP 7111/3
Economy
Bruttosozialprodukt (easy)
EP 517/3
BH 5440/5
WP 1208/1
Stagflation (medium)
EP 0/0
BH 5380/5
WP 1890/3
Leverage-Effekt (hard)
EP 0/0
BH 473/3
WP 744/5
Religion
Augustinus (easy)
EP 9534/4
BH 12879/5
WP 9002/4
Pantokrator (medium)
EP 446/4
BH 251/4
WP 352/4
Monophysiten (hard)
EP 1600/4
BH 1438/5
WP 2811/4
Sport
Rochade (easy)
EP 1108/4
BH 209/2
WP 1635/5
Eishockey: Abseitsregel (medium)
EP 397/4
BH 0/0
WP 505/5
Pauschenpferd (hard)
EP 0/0
BH 379/5
WP 307/4
Eating/drinking
Ouzo (easy)
EP 210/4
BH 41/3
WP 612/5
Schupfnudeln (medium)
EP 0/0
BH 0/0
WP 704/5
Kapaun (hard)
EP 0/0
BH 428/3
WP 1547/5
==========================================================
Cultural area
==========================================================
Educating art (?)/architecture
Bauhaus (easy)
EP 8882/4
BH 3959/3
WP 9191/5
dorisches Kapitell (medium)
EP 3257/4
BH 1225/3
WP 263/4
Sfumato (hard)
EP 847/3
BH 1344/3
WP 506/3
Literature
Alexandriner (easy)
EP 1216/5
BH 399/3
WP 745/4
Ulysses (medium)
EP 4561/5
BH 817/3
WP 1438/3
Albert Vigoleis Thelen (hard)
EP 2748/5
BH 337/3
WP 679/4
Music
Maultrommel (easy)
EP 960/5
BH 883/4
WP 546/2
wohltemperiertes Klavier (medium)
EP 799/3
BH 0/0
WP 3146/4
Quartsext-Akkord (hard)
EP 510/3
BH 121/5
WP 470/3
Movie/theatre
Brüder Lumière (easy)
EP 4294/3
BH 3619/4
WP 0/0
Katharsis (medium)
EP 5439/5
BH 5245/2
WP 838/4
Pina Bausch (hard)
EP 1359/3
BH 1759/4
WP 1480/3
Myths/sagas/fairy tales
Charybdis (easy)
EP 2193/4
BH 2136/5
WP 855/2
Leprechaun (medium)
EP 0/0
BH 0/0
WP 788/5
Yggdrasil (hard)
EP 562/4
BH 768/4
WP 877/3
Now I need a new keyboard.
Regards, Lothar
--
Lothar Kimmeringer E-Mail: spamfang at kimmeringer.de
PGP-encrypted mails preferred (Key-ID: 0x8BC3CD81)
Always remember: The answer is forty-two, there can only be wrong
questions!
More information about the Wikipedia-l
mailing list