When you get bach to that message by daniwo59(a)aol.com
you will find , that [[Dany]] titled his message:
Helga and other Internet kooks.
I am glag to see that no one has answered him on that (yet).
I, for one, object to Dany's namecalling. It is inappropriate and namecalling should
not be a wikipedia function.
I will post the /talk, that took place here:
Aloha? had posted 50.000, Danny changed it to 5.000 . What is the number?
The next part was also taken out, which should be shown, especially in light of todays
goings on and the previous talk, which seems to try to make them into a hate group, which
they specifically reject.
Though they number just some 50000, their vociferous attacks against Zionism and Israel as
a secular state have earned them considerable attention. They instead argue that the true
Israel can only be reestablished with the coming of the Messiah. The Neturei Karta website
shows Israeli police clobbering the Torah-True Neturei Karta. They stand for the rights of
the Palestinians and have good relations with the PLO and other Palestinian and Muslim
organizations. Nowhere on their website does it state, that they hate Jews or anyone else.
They state that they are against the (militant) Zionists violence, against them supressing
Palestinians and against the Zionists wars including the 1933 war-declaration then and the
possibility of all-out war now.
Their website seems to say something to the effect of 100.000 followers?
H. Jonat
Helga, as the person who wrote the first draft of this article I do know a little about
the subject. In fact, I did not look at the website when writing the article--I based it
on my own independent research on the phenomenon of Neturei Karta, my close personal
interactions with members of the community, and my readings and interpretations of their
own texts and the texts of sociologists and anthropologists who studied them.
To clarify some of the points you bring up: a website is hardly an informative account of
a group. Anybody can put up a website and say whatever they want about anything, including
themselves. It is an interesting source of information, no doubt, but the Internet per se
is not always a reliable source. As regards Neturei Karta, I have a lot of problems with
the website. For one, it is based in America, when the overwhelming majority of genuine
Neturei Karta members live in Jerusalem. Then, of course, the vast majority of members of
Neturei Karta would not own a computer, since this would bring them into contact with the
outside world, and that is something they shun. The numbers are based on statistics from
the Municipality of Jerusalem to which I have had formal access over the past few years.
There are other groups which identify with Neturei Karta, but they are not Neturei Karta
(Karta is an Aramaic term for "the city", meaning Jerusalem). Other anti-Zionist
ultra-Orthodox groups such as Satmar are not Neturei Karta.
I removed the section beginning with "The Neturei Karta website shows ... " Yes
it does. Do you know why they were "clobbered"? Because they were throwing rocks
and bottles at cars driving on a highway in Jerusalem on the Sabbath. They wanted the
highway to be closed for the Sabbath. An ambulance carrying a heart attack victim was hit
with one of their rocks. How do I know this? I was there. Despite what the website
implies, they were not "clobbered" because they are anti-Zionist. For the most
part, the Israeli government leaves them alone. They barely even collect taxes from them.
As for hating Jews, if you will look in the record of this discussion, I actually rejected
the notion that they were anti-Semitic. I wrote this article to offer a fair presentation
of their views, even though personally I may not share them.
As for the "Zionist declaration of war," I have spoken with many Neturei Karta
about many issues, including their attitudes toward Zionists, the Holocaust, and Nazism.
Not one Neturei Karta member will tell you that the Jews or the Zionists initiated or
sparked World War II. They do not even say that on their website. They do claim that
Zionist actions made things worse for the Jews, and they do claim that the Holocaust was
Divine retribution for the secular lifestyles of the Zionists. I will not get into a
debate here about the way God works (if at all). I would like to examine their claim,
which you seem to support. Looking at their website, which you cite, they give examples of
how the Zionists made things worse. Hitler wanted to deport all the Jews from Europe to
Mauritius (sounds like ethnic cleansing to me). The Zionists opposed it and they should
have said yes, because in Neturei Karta's philosophy, Jews should be subservient to
Gentiles until the coming of the Messiah. Now lets plug the statement into your assertion
here and in the mailing list that the Holocaust was largely caused because some Jews (the
Zionists) refused to be ethnically cleansed. Sorry, but that is anti-Semitic, and I do not
use that term lightly. If I were to say that the German residents of Prussia were justly
killed after World War II because they did not want to be expelled from Prussia, you could
rightfully call me racist. How is the case of Jews in Europe any different.
An interesting anecdote is that Ruth Blau, the widow of the late leader of Neturei Karta,
Rabbi Amram Blau, is a French Catholic convert to Judaism. She met her husband when she
part of the French underground, helping to smuggle Jews out of Europe during the Nazi
reign of terror. She would never tell you that the Jews were responsible for the
Holocaust, even if she would say that the Holocaust was God's retribution for the sins
of some Jews, including the Zionists.
Finally, Helga, like everyone has already said: Examine your sources, examine your
citations. Not every website is historically accurate. Not every historical claim has
basis. I've avoided getting into this debate until now, but Helga, please realize that
there are other people out there whose professional and academic fields do encompass your
own interests. We also know our stuff, so if you don't want to get into vociferous
arguments, please make sure your facts and interpretations are valid. Danny
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Danny I appreciate all your information. Believe me, I did/do not want to get into this
either. I do know that there are a lot more Jewish people opposed to the radical violence
perpetuated by the current situation. I do know that a Lady Ambassador (name?) came from
Israel was on an emergency trip and on Ted Koppel's Night Line. She warned about the
militant brutal force and worse put upon by a rivaling faction against other Jews. There
are ladies or grandmothers in grey (or black),opposing , with Israeli soldiers attending.
There is a lot more going on, than what the official version wants you to believe. I do
not wish harm on any one or any one group. Therefore I have this feeling, that getting
previous happenings out in the open, can somehow make a difference. Now everyone wants to
make this 1933 Declaration of War out to be a 'minor little none-issue', not worse
mentioning. But when you read the wiki or any other article that says, "the
Nazi's forbade Germans to buy from Jewish stores", then it makes a lot more sense
to say 'why', and the 'why' is the Decleration of War. Another factor not
readily mentioned, is the Deal between Germany and Jewish people (Zionists), who since
before 1900 already moved to Palestine and who continued to do so under the Nazi
dictatorship. They took a lot of money out of Germany and started building the Jewish
State, (some program named Havala? or something like this). I would not argue about any of
the loud arguments, because I do not know enough details on this. Therefore I ask
questions. Which brings me to the question on the numbers again. I guess until we know, we
should just leave the numbers off alltogether? H. Jonat
Helga, your ramblings here show that you have know idea what you are talking about, and I
am being very polite in saying that. Personally, I find it insulting that you insinuate
that I am a victim of some "official version" and not "the truth."
Unlike you, I actually do know something about the topics mentioned here. For your
information, we were talking about Neturei Karta, a reactionary group of a few thousand
followers that opposes the state of Israel on principle, believing that Jews should be
subservient to Gentiles until the Messiah comes. That is not some interpretation. That is
what they say in their internal texts. I have read those texts. Women in Black is a
grassroots organization of Israeli women opposed to the occupation of the West Bank. Yes,
many Israelis are disturbed by the violence in Israeli society. I am also deeply concerned
about the violence in Israeli society. This has little to do with Neturei Karta. It has to
do with the Occupation. Period. Hitler and the Nazis did not forbid Germans to buy from
Jews because of the so-called "Declaration of War." That is asinine. Are you
ignoring Mein Kampf? Are you ignoring the Nazi campaign platform prior to Hitler coming to
power? Are you ignoring Hitler's speeches and writings. We have records of all of
them. We even have the records of Hitler's first public appearance at the German
Worker's Party. (I have a copy in my office, if you'd like.) It was an
anti-Semitic diatribe, plain and simple. It was also before any Nazi was elected to the
Reichstag. Jews did not have any deal with the German government to move to Palestine.
They fled Germany because of rampant anti-Semitism. As for your dates, political Zionism
was founded in 1896. Herzl, the founder of the movement, negotiated unsuccessfully with
the Kaiser to get a German protectorate in the region so that Jews could settle there.
Until the 1930s, Jewish immigrants to Palestine came from Russia, not Germany. As for
taking money out of Germany, they were fleeing for their lives. Some managed to take money
out. Most did not. Most could not. It was illegal. Many spent all their money paying
bribes to officials to get their children to England. It was called the Kindertransport. I
am glad you admit you don't know much about this topic. It so happens that I do. As
for the number of Neturei Karta members, at least you admit that you do not know it. Once
again, I have studied this issue. I do have reasons for the numbers I give, and not just
some stupid website. If you don't know the subject matter, don't writre about it.
Better to be thought a fool than to open your mouth and prove it beyond a doubt. A very
irate Danny
------------------
To this [[Neturei Karta]]/Talk beteen Dany and myself I want to add, that 1. The number is
still not substanciated.
2. Not only the Neturei Karta, but also the
http://www.jewsnotzionist.org/ and the Woman
in Black (or Women for Peace)
http://adot.com/green/wib.html are demonstrating against
Israeli violence etc. Contrary to Dany's denial of the there are people , who claim to
have information, that in fact the Havaara undertaking was handled by later Israeli prime
ministers incl Ben Gurion, Moshe Sharret(or Shertok), Golda Meir, Levi Eshkol
http://www.codoh.com/zionweb/zionmythgar.2.html
google.com : Havaara , or
Google.com Women in Balck, gives a number of websites.
I am only bringing all this up, because of Dany's bad choice of a website title: Helga
and other Internet cooks. I also want to substanciate my talk to Dany, that there are a
lot more facts , that the general public is not aware of. I also stated that I do not want
to get anyone hurt and that I have a great concern for people wanting to make war, war
war... It was also before I found out that Dany works in the Holocaust memorial, which
some writers
including Jewish writers, might call the Holocaust industry.
This is all I want to say about this.
H. Jonat
--
__________________________________________________________
Sign-up for your own FREE Personalized E-mail at
Mail.com
http://www.mail.com/?sr=signup