[Wikipedia-l] Re: how to deal with uncooperative users

[Fred Bauder]

Many times folks simply don't understand something and can eventually be 
brought along. Trying several times would seem to be better than just once. 
Some of the other suggestions like revert after two weeks are very good and 
energy conserving.

It's a good rule in personal relations to assume people do not change, but 
perhaps a better practice to have faith that they can provided not too much 
is risked on the effort.

Fred

Message: 9
To: wikipedia-l at nupedia.com
Date: 25 Oct 2002 11:48:33 +0200
From: elian <elian at gmx.li>
Subject: [Wikipedia-l] how to deal with uncooperative users
Reply-To: wikipedia-l at nupedia.com


Hello,

I followed the ongoing debate about how to deal with uncooperative users
with some astonishment. Some people seem to forget the first rule of
online-communities: Don't feed the trolls!

Precisely, it depends largely on each one's personal attitude how to deal
with jerks.

First, try to discuss only once. If your adversary does not answer in a
way you regard as serious, is insulting or refuses to substantiate claims
with arguments, immediately stop discussion - forever or until you see
somewhere else that he has changed his attitude. Don't try to educate
people except you specially  like to do this. Don't feel responsible for
a jerk's metal health!

Second, take your time. Let him have his way, put the article on your
watchlist and silently revert the changes two weeks later without further
discussion. Time is on the side of the regulars, not the jerks.

Third, just an idea: to feel not so alone, you could put up a page
[[Wikipedia:Annoying users]] where you could state your feelings. If
enough votes come up on one person, this person could _ eventually_  be
banned.

Just my experiences from the German wikipedia where we had almost no edit
wars at all up to now. We have questionable contributions, some are
silently moved to talk pages, some are rewritten. Discussion is tried
once, after this fails the person is simply ignored.


just my two cents,
elian
--
Computers are like Airconditioners - they stop working properly when
you open windows





_________________________________________________________________
Get faster connections -- switch to MSN Internet Access! 
http://resourcecenter.msn.com/access/plans/default.asp