I couldn't agree more with Risker. I'm afraid that such a huge preparedness
would damage the option that less experienced speakers can present too. I
also wouldn't be in favor of a lot of plenary sessions - my experience
tells me that at least *I* have been more often disappointed by a keynote
speaker than positively surprised. This year's Charles Mok was a very
positive exception on that. But maybe that is simply because I've attended
too many Wikimania's :)
On the other hand what I always liked so much about Wikimania /was/ exactly
the amount of choice. What I questioned was that the sessions basically
continue through the breaks - I'm simply afraid that this is very
exhausting (which everybody so far seems to confirm).
Something what I *would* like to see changed about the schedule is more
discussions with experienced discussion leaders. Not like this year when it
was basically a run-out-time for the session before, but a dedicated track,
with a dedicated discussion coordinator that puts together the discussion
track only a few days in advance to ensure that the most recent topics are
covered too. In that way I hope that you also have an improved experience -
that track could be somewhat run like you suggested (with someone preparing
the discussion etc) and should indeed of course be documented! I just
don't think the whole schedule should be like that.
Lodewijk
2013/8/15 Risker <risker.wp(a)gmail.com>
On 15 August 2013 00:03, Samuel Klein <meta.sj(a)gmail.com> wrote:
Wikimania should have less parallel sessions,
< longer sessions with more time between the sessions
> and an "open space" as an additional track.
<>
> We implemented this idea last year at the
WikiCon...
<> I am a strong believer that less is actually more. I would like
to have
a less
stressful but more effictive Wikimania.
Your ideas are welcomed by me :) I've been wanting fewer sessions at
Wikimania for a long time.
I agree totally. We can rethink the traditional program entirely.
Imagine a Wikimania where
* the only "talks" or presentations are Plenary sessions
* all other sessions
** have their documents/drawings/slides/tools published 2 weeks in
advance, for others to read / comment / link
** have Q&A handled online in advance of the event (via comments and
discussion)
** are group discussions or collaborations around a topic, not one-way
presentations
** are moderated by someone who is good at moderation (this may or may
not be the primary author of works being discussed)
** update the latest documentation about those ideas/projects/tools
live, during the session (via a designated facilitator/editor)
I dunno. That sounds fundamentally unwiki, and an awful lot like the
professional annual meetings that everyone hates attending. It weighs
heavily in favour of "professional" presenters and those who think that the
powerpoint is more important than the presentation. I wouldn't spring for a
plane ticket for something like this.
As it is, I know for a fact that most of the sessions presented this year
were finalized no more than a week before their presentation, and quite a
few included "up to the minute" information and data. This is particularly
important in an environment that is constantly changing.
What I'd like to see is live-streaming of sessions with moderation that
could include online questions for the sessions.
Wikimania is primarily a social event - and that includes the "developer
days" at the beginning. Some sessions are of professional quality, some
others gain their energy from the presentation itself or the perceived
importance of the topic, and others simply by being presented by sincere
and caring community members. The best session I saw this year was one
that would never meet the bars described above - it was about the Javanese
Wikipedia, and it was the one that was so full of hope and joy at the
prospect of sharing knowledge freely that the few of us who were in the
room walked away with a refreshed sense of what our movement is all about.
You can't capture that with slides or plenary sessions or expert
moderation. You need to be in the room.
Risker
_______________________________________________
Wikimania-l mailing list
Wikimania-l(a)lists.wikimedia.org
https://lists.wikimedia.org/mailman/listinfo/wikimania-l