[WikiEN-l] How to do something about AFD

Ray Saintonge saintonge at telus.net
Mon Mar 10 10:34:59 UTC 2008


David Gerard wrote:
> On 09/03/2008, Nathan <nawrich at gmail.com> wrote:
>   
>> Generally, well referenced articles don't get deleted at AfD. So, it isn't
>>  like we're losing our best content here. The WQA on David is a bit
>>  ridiculous, though, and the criticism from an admin that "you've been an
>>  editor since 2004, you should know better!" doesn't seem calculated to
>>  actually do any good. Etiquette police... When was the last MfD for WP:WQA?
>>     
> Notice also the complete refusal to address the question "so how would
> you phrase severely defective judgement on the part of a nominator?"
> Said severely defective judgement being much of the problem with AFD.
>
> This is going to take interested parties diving in. This means you.
Yes. Sigh!  It must have taken me an hour to go through a half-dozen of 
these nominations. I know fuck-all about Austrian rock bands or New 
Zealand soap operas.

Anyway, I added a small flame to the WQA nomination.

Ec



More information about the WikiEN-l mailing list