On Sun, Mar 02, 2008 at 02:20:22AM +0000, geni wrote:
On 02/03/2008, WJhonson(a)aol.com
<WJhonson(a)aol.com> wrote:
In a message dated 3/1/2008 5:39:30 P.M. Pacific Standard Time,
geniice(a)gmail.com writes:
The author is free to release the image under a free license should
they wish to do so.>>
--
Or since we have 200K non-free images, they are also free to cite a fair-use
critieria.
Fair use doesn't work like that (okey I admit I'm not totaly certain
what would happen since no one is yet to take such a monumentally
stupid case to court). You appear to think that fair use is some magic
incarnation that can make all your copyright issues go away it does
not. If fact it makes them worse. Fair use is hard. It is case law
rather than statute law driven. That means that not only are their
vast grey areas but there are random islands of black and white in the
greyness that you are unlikely to know about. On top of that rather a
lot of it is subject to change without warning.
Now it is possible to cope with all this but so far you have failed to
demonstrate the level of knowledge that suggests you could do so.
Now thats fine. Wikipedia accepts that most people don't know that
much about copyright law so we work around it. We try and create a
system people can follow which is where the bureaucracy comes from.
Claiming fair use on your own work makes no friggin sense (unless you
no longer hold the copyright) no matter how you try and dodge around
the point thus we are not going to change policy to white list those
who try.
Maybe I am one of those people who does not understand this.
If I had an article on WP and I uploaded an image of me and put it on
my article claiming fair use, what is the problem? First, I am not going
to sue. Second, it can not then be used by any Tom, Dick or Harry
anywhere they like, which would have been the case if I had uploaded
using the GFDL or into the public domain. I can see lots of reasons why
I might want to do that.
If this is not possible, how could I achieve this outcome - it goes on
my page with my approval but nowhere else?
I am assuming that fair use is OK in general. I could upload an image
from anyway of a person and put it on their article under fair use,
could I not? Is'nt that one of the criteria for fair use?
--
geni
_______________________________________________
WikiEN-l mailing list
WikiEN-l(a)lists.wikimedia.org
To unsubscribe from this mailing list, visit:
https://lists.wikimedia.org/mailman/listinfo/wikien-l
--
Brian Salter-Duke b_duke(a)bigpond.net.au
[[User:Bduke]] mainly on en:Wikipedia.
Also on fr: Wikipedia, Meta-Wiki and Wikiversity