[WikiEN-l] Short-lived retreat

[Flame Viper]

Well, the legal threats turned out to be BS, so I'm back. And rightfully so.

In response to the attacks against my "limited admin" idea, I would like to defend my position.

The "demisysop" status (as I have taken the liberty of calling it) would be much like the sysop status. It would be subject to much of the restrictions of sysop; you would have to demonstrate acumen and have responsibility, NPOV, understanding of policy, etc.

So nobody's going to get something they don't deserve. And nobody will be deprived.

The point of this status is so that excellent EDITORS (not vandalfighters,  arbitrators, etc) would be able to have special tools that would allow them to easily edit.
The problem is that there are two different fields of Wikipedia work: Editing and maintenance. Editing is the general writing and improvement of articles, citing, cleanup, categorisation, etc. Maintenance is the vandalfighting, blocking, arbitrating, mediating, and policy that provides the framework for the wiki.

Sysop tools are designed for maintenance, and too often, the mop is awarded or declined based on editing.

The "writer" class would solve that.

 
---------------------------------
We won't tell. Get more on shows you hate to love
(and love to hate): Yahoo! TV's Guilty Pleasures list.