[WikiEN-l] Admins and elitism

[Ray Saintonge]

Rich Holton wrote:

>Given the recent discussions on this list, and the continuing increase 
>in de-facto requirements for new admins, I have to wonder if we are not 
>now well on the way to the creation of an elite class on Wikipedia.
>
Nah!  It's more like the time of the French Revolution when all citizens 
were equal but some were more equal than others.

>It appears to me that the vocal representatives of the current crop of 
>admins (meaning those who have become admins within the last year or so) 
>  have left far behind the idea that being an admin is "no big deal". 
>They see being an admin as a big deal, and want things to remain that way.
>
It's called self-interest.

>Of course, the admins point to the very real challenges that vandals 
>pose as the reason for the rigor of the application process. They reject 
>any proposal that might place Wikipedia is peril.
>
Right!  The right to bear arms is justified because it keeps America 
safe from being overrun by elephants.

>Perhaps they're right. I'm certain that they truly want what it best for 
>Wikipedia.
>
As the saying goes: "The road to hell is paved with good intentions."

Ec