[WikiEN-l] Primary sources

Jonathan dzonatas at dzonux.net
Fri Mar 17 05:52:40 UTC 2006


Hello,

If someone uses a primary source, should the context be quoted directly? 
If it is not, would that constitute original research? Another words, if 
someone takes the primary source and interprets it to his or her own 
need, it does seem like a re-creation of a primary source. It's like 
original research in an attempt to make the primary source a secondary 
source.

I've seen this kind of discussion before. The result was that all 
scholarly work is always based on secondary scholastic sources. That 
does not give an answer to the primary sources as above, but it does 
shed some insight into non-scholarly source creep.

Feedback is appreciated.

Jonathan



More information about the WikiEN-l mailing list