On 7/14/06, Ben Yates <bluephonic(a)gmail.com> wrote:
There was a wikipedia guideline that I can't
remember the name of --
something like "show, don't just tell": if you're writing an article
[[WP:GRAPEFRUIT]], from memory.
about trees it's good to have a photo of a tree;
if you're writing
about music, it's good to have a sound clip. This is the same
principle. Should we remove all the photos at [[Tree]] because
they're not totally reprentative of all trees? It seems like the
solution for [[Joke]] is to get an expert review, not to bulldoze a
shabby but vibrant public space.
Totally agree with you. An article about jokes that does not have
enough examples to illustrate the concept of a joke is remiss. On the
other hand, an article about jokes that includes 50 examples is also
in error.
Steve