actionforum(a)comcast.net wrote:
-------------- Original message --------------
As I understand it, it is a blockable offence to
change another's
comments. Do you have a link to the appropriate page?
Chris
They are changing their mutually certified statement of dispute
at
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia_talk:Requests_for_comment/Silverback
So in a sense it is changing their own comments, but it is after I have
responded, so it is changing the meaning of my responses, etc. I still think to
protect the integrity of my response, etc. The should make changes in a
separate section where they respond to my responses, etc. I am a little
surprised that they would give
each other carte blanche to make changes above
each others signature. I don't
think they have all agreed to that yet either.
-- Silverback
Perhaps in your response to the points raised by the other people you
could quote what they are saying, to ensure that it is clear what you
are responding to?
Chris
The signed the statement of Dispute and then notified me. They shouldn't be changing
it underneath my responses. Yes, I could quote them, because they might delete from
underneath me, but what is an RfC/user doing lacking even the basic integrity of a talk
page. You were right the first time. It is a blockable offense. But I wanted you to
know that some of the community seems to think nothing of this behavior.
-- Silverback