This is exactly the problem of government: For any society with goals, how best to reach
those goals?
In the general social sense, the term used is
"coersion," ie. use of violence (acted or implied) to gain influence. The
authoritarian concept of "rule of law" is largely about shifting violence from
the acted form to its implied form.
On a free, principled and entirely volunteer project, coersive methods are out of
reasonable bounds, and IMHO the term "guidance" is preferable. On Wikipedia
there has only been one accepted authority (Jimbo) and his continued defacto authority
rests more on his egalitarian philosophy and organization capability than on any
self-appointed titles etc. Otherwise people would just say "fork him" - ;-)
But now there seems to be a leadership gap on en.wikipedia -- where pencil rules written
by ad-hoc concensus are generally unreviewable even by the Arbcom. In that context, yes,
the notion of 'making people do stuff' seems rather rude and lacks any meaning.
Even when there is community or committee consensus, if its consensus without
responsiveness or rationality, then (not unlike our recent 'page views' rank on
Alexa) a case of 'one step forward two steps back.'
SV
dpbsmith(a)verizon.net wrote: If something is mandatory on Wikipedia, that means that if you
want people to
follow it you need to _convince_ them that a) it is mandatory, b) they should
follow things that are mandatory.
Just like absolutely everything else on Wikipedia.
How can you "enforce" anything like that except by jawboning?
A "mandate," the dictionary says, is "An authoritative command or
instruction." But what, exactly, does "authoritative" mean on Wikipedia?
Who's going to enforce these "mandates?" Is Jimbo Wales is personally going
to micromanage discussions on talk pages? Are we going to restrict the "move"
button to Bureaucrats?
To riff on Mark Twain (or perhaps it was Oscar Wilde, or Dorothy Parker):
How many mandatory policies do we have if we call the Manual of Style
mandatory?
Answer: We have none, because calling a policy mandatory doesn't make it one.
---------------------------------
Yahoo! FareChase - Search multiple travel sites in one click.