On 11/12/05, Delirium <delirium(a)hackish.org> wrote:
There's an informal (formal?) rule that if a
majority of arbitrators
ever recuse on a case, they all are automatically unrecused. The
justification is that, in all probability, a situation that resulted in
a user having personal conflicts with nearly every single arbitrator is
more likely to be the fault of the user than the fault individually of
every arbitrator. A more practical justification is that it serves as a
deterrent to trying to "win" a case by forcing everyone to recuse.
-Mark
No. Last time we disscussed this the general conclusion was that we
would call up past arbcom members and people from other languages if
posible. The solution you list runs into the problem that if you have
multiple sibjects to abitration it is posible for none of them to have
gone overboard in dissputes.
--
geni