On 04/29/2011 05:40 PM, Bryan Tong Minh wrote: Thanks for already adding that to http://www.mediawiki.org/wiki/Berlin_Hackathon_2011#More_Ideas . -Sumana

sorry for the re-post ( having trouble with the wikitech-l list post email migration :( I would also be interested in discussing this in Berlin or otherwise ;) I can offer some notes about video embedding inline: On 04/29/2011 03:30 PM, Brion Vibber wrote: along, of the you can interested in and other It appears the iframe embed method is becoming somewhat standardise way to share videos. With Youtube, Vimeo, and others providing it as an option to deliver both flash and html5 players. The bit of HTML that you copy on commons share video function is just an iframe ( similar to those other sites ). Timed Media Handler works the same way using the same url parameter ( embedplayer=yes ) so that we can seamlessly replace the 'fancy media player' rewrite with a similar embed player page delivered by the TMH extension [1] The iframe player lets you sandbox the player when you embed it in foreign domain contexts, and enables you to deliver the interface that includes things like the credits screen that parses our description template page on commons to present credit information and a link back to the description page. As iframe embed is relatively standard, we simply have to request that our domain be white listed for it to be shared on facebook , wordpress etc. In addition to working as a pure iframe without xss javascript, to support mashups like the googles player [2] if you include a bit of JS where you embed the iframe, the mwEmbed player also has an iframe api that lets you use the HTML5 video api on the iframe as if it was a video tag in the page. [3] oEmbed is a nice way to consistently 'discover' embed code and media properties. Its implementation within mediaWiki would be akin to supporting RSS or OpenSearch, so I think its something we should try and do. As the spec currently stands its api for the "embed code" rather than an api for mashups. I think more interesting things could be done in addition to the iframe, object tag and basic metadata ... like giving the urls to all the media files, and urls to all the associated timed text of a given player ... Something like the ROE standard [4] that we ( xiph, annodex ) folks were talking about a while back might be a good direction to extend oEmbed into. ( Although commercial video service sites are not likely to be interested in mash-ups outside of "their player" hence oEmbed leaning toward 'html' to embed the players... direct links to associated media is one of those standard ideas that in theory is good, but does not play well with video service business models ... but that does not have stop us / oEmbed from promoting it :) I would also add the TMH adds a separate api entry point to deliver some of this info such as the urls for all the derivatives related to a particular media title [5]. I would like to add associated timed text listing to that videoinfo prop and from there it should not be hard to adapt that to a ROE or oEmbed v2 type representation. [1] http://prototype.wikimedia.org/timedmedia/Main_Page#Iframe_embed_and_viral_… [2] http://code.google.com/apis/youtube/iframe_api_reference.html [3] http://svn.wikimedia.org/svnroot/mediawiki/trunk/extensions/TimedMediaHandl… [4] http://wiki.xiph.org/index.php/ROE [5] http://prototype.wikimedia.org/tmh/api.php?action=query&titles=File:Shu…