On 1/7/06, Ben Emmel <bratsche1(a)gmail.com>
wrote:
On 1/6/06, Zzyzx11 at Wikipedia
<zzyzx11(a)hotmail.com> wrote:
>
> Here's something that crossed my mind:
>
> As the number of userboxes continues to increase, I am starting to see
a
> number of them that are currently NOT being
used by ANYONE. So in a
couple
> weeks from now, if these same userboxes are
still not being used on
any
userpage,
shouldn't they be put on TFD like any other unused, orphaned
template? Why or why not?
Zzyzx11 at
en.wikipedia.org
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/User:Zzyzx11
zzyzx11(a)hotmail.com
Check out [[WP:TFD]] right now. Currently, there is a whole bunch of
userbox warriors that are going to stall and keep any userbox that comes
their way. In short, the box is going to get kept anyways. An example of
this is {{User fair use}}, which Jimbo himself deleted before being
informed
of the TfD debate, which is really irrelevant,
considering that we can't
disobey the US copyright law that Wikipedia is legally obligated to
fllow.
Looks to me that the userbox editors are disrupting the flow and work of
Wikipedia, but I'd be interested to hear what others think. Those who
have
five times as many userbox edits as mainspace
edits can't be helping
Wikipedia all that much.
I hope the admin who decides closes the {{User fair use}} debate
evaluates the quality of the arguments made in relation to the
encyclopedia's mission; it'll be deleted then.
SCZenz
Unused userboxes that have been around for a while (i.e. not created in the
immediate past) should definitely be deleted (aside from those that fill a
pattern, such as Babel langauges/levels where no-one speaks it yet). Are
there any arguments for keeping these userboxes? Alternatively, I would also
argue for the deletion of all userboxes only used by one person (and the
userbox has been around for some time): what's the point of having a
template and category for something only one person is going to use? We
could just tell the person to substitute it on his/her userpage instead.
Thoughts on that? Thanks!
Flcelloguy
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia.
_________________________________________________________________
Is your PC infected? Get a FREE online computer virus scan from McAfee®
Security.